Two young German travelers with ESTA travel authorization jailed and deported

Two young German travelers expected their Hawaii trip to be the highlight of a months-long world adventure. Instead, their visit ended in handcuffs, jail time, and deportation — a stark reminder of the risks some international visitors face at U.S. borders.

This story was first reported in Germany’s Ostsee-Zeitung newspaper, a major regional daily that has been published for over seventy years. The German Foreign Office confirmed its involvement in the case, providing consular support after the travelers were detained in Honolulu.

Why U.S. border officials flagged their travel plans.

Charlotte Pohl, 19, and Maria Lepere, 18, arrived in Honolulu from Auckland with plans to explore Hawaii before continuing to California and Costa Rica. However, their flexible travel style — including a lack of pre-booked lodging for their planned five-week Hawaii stay — raised red flags for U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP).

Despite having ESTA travel authorization, the two were accused of potential illegal work intentions, a common concern for border officials screening young travelers without fixed plans.

The German Foreign Office later reminded travelers that ESTA approval does not guarantee entry to the U.S. — a decision always left to border officials at the point of arrival.

What happens when travelers get detained in Hawaii.

The travelers described their detention experience as shocking and surreal.

After hours of questioning at Honolulu Airport, they said they were placed in handcuffs, loaded into a transport vehicle, and brought to what they later learned was a deportation detention facility.

There, they reported being subjected to full-body scans, strip searches, and issued green prison uniforms. They were placed in a holding cell overnight alongside long-term detainees, including individuals accused of serious crimes.

Conditions described included sleeping on thin, moldy mattresses, using rudimentary toilets, and being warned by guards to avoid expired food.

The following morning, the travelers were escorted back to Honolulu Airport in handcuffs and deported — not to Germany, but to Japan, at their request, avoiding a longer return trip to New Zealand.

Recent reports suggest growing travel hesitation on both sides of the Atlantic.

Some U.S. travelers are expressing uncertainty about how they’ll be received in parts of Europe. At the same time, European visitors are raising concerns about stricter U.S. border enforcement, with fears of detention or deportation now influencing travel plans.

United States Secretary of State, Marco Rubio, has tried to ease concerns of European travelers wanting to visit the USA by saying, “If you’re not coming to the United States to join a Hamas protest, or to come here and tell us about how right Hamas is, or…stir up conflict on our campuses and create riots in our streets and vandalize our universities, then you have nothing to worry about.”

Why ESTA approval doesn’t guarantee entry to Hawaii.

The ESTA (Electronic System for Travel Authorization) allows citizens of certain countries to travel to the U.S. for short stays without a visa. However, ESTA approval permits travel to a U.S. port of entry, where border officials have the final say on whether to grant entry.

In many cases, travelers without clear lodging plans, a well-defined itinerary, or proof of sufficient funds may be denied entry. U.S. officials may also raise concerns if they suspect a visitor could be planning to work illegally or stay beyond their permitted time. Even honest answers about working remotely or being flexible with travel plans can raise additional questions that may not end well for some visitors.

In this case, the travelers said their spontaneous, flexible travel style — common in places like New Zealand and Thailand — did not translate well when entering the U.S., where stricter documentation is often expected.

Germany’s updated travel advisory now explicitly warns that “entry to the United States is at the sole discretion of U.S. border authorities.”

What Hawaii visitors should know now.

This case highlights the importance of preparation and documentation for anyone planning a trip to Hawaii from abroad. Travelers should expect to clearly explain their travel plans, show proof of accommodations for their entire stay, and provide evidence of onward or return travel.

Visitors must also have proof of sufficient funds to support themselves while in Hawaii and be ready to answer detailed questions from U.S. border officials. A vague or incomplete explanation of travel plans could lead to delays, further questioning, or even denial of entry.

While most international visitors experience no issues entering Hawaii, this case serves as a cautionary reminder that what works in other countries may not work when dealing with U.S. immigration authorities.

Broader concerns for Hawaii tourism.

Stories like this could impact Hawaii’s image, particularly among international visitors facing high costs and growing overtourism concerns.

With global media coverage of this case and broader concerns spreading through Germany and Europe, some travelers may reconsider their Hawaii plans or choose destinations perceived as more welcoming.

Hawaii’s reputation as a dream destination depends not only on its natural beauty but also on the overall visitor experience. That includes what happens when travelers step off the plane and enter immigration and customs.

The bottom line for Hawaii visitors.

Whether arriving from Germany, Canada, Australia, or anywhere else, international visitors to Hawaii must be fully prepared for the possibility of detailed questioning at the border. As these young visitors learned, ESTA is a travel authorization, not a guaranteed ticket into Hawaii.

Understanding the process and preparing accordingly can help avoid the risk of detention or deportation, and ensure Hawaii remains the dream trip it was always intended to be.

Hawaii became unforgettable for these two young visitors for all the wrong reasons. Their story is a cautionary tale for future visitors from abroad.

We welcome your comments.